• Home
  • About
  • Cycling
    • Sportives
    • Garmin Edge 800
  • Video
  • Social media
  • Music
  • Local Gov
  • Blog
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact

Maps comparison – free OSM and OS Discoverer.

Feb01
2012
3 Comments Written by Alan

After installing the TalkyToaster OpenStreetmap onto my Garmin Edge 800 (see tutorial here) I think it will come in quite useful after all.

I do prefer the look of the classic OS discoverer map when in the middle zoom levels, but I think the OSM map will excel in the fine details of the close up.
The screenshots below attempt to show this, with the Velomap thrown in for comparison.


The screenshots shown at the end of the video appear below.
I’ve shown 4 zoom levels, which can be gauged by the scale marker at the top of each screenshot.

They go down from 5 miles, 1.2 miles, 0.2 miles and 200 feet.

TalkyToaster OSM

Velomap OSM

Ordnance Survey Discoverer

My observations:

  • Velomap looks quite pale and bland on the Garmin screen, as it lacks contrast.
  • Talkytoaster seems very usable at all zoom levels, though because it’s based on OSM, some smaller roads may not have been mapped yet.
  • Discoverer maps look great in the mid range but are poor when zoomed in too far. (Update: I’ve posted screenshots of every available zoom level in this post.)

An ideal compromise would be for the Garmin device to display the Discoverer map at mid zoom and then switch to the TalkyToaster map for the ultra high zooms.
But at this stage, I’m not sure if it can do such a thing.
Can anyone shed any light on that?

Get the TalkyToaster map for FREE here

You can get the Edge 800 plus the Discoverer maps from Wiggle Online Cycle Shop

Buy from Wiggle

Buy from Wiggle

 

Related Posts :

Tutorial: How to export anyone's Strava ride ...
Garmin maps comparison - City Navigator and O...
10 reasons to ditch phone apps and get a prop...
OS Discoverer maps: screenshot zoom levels (G...
  • Please share:
  • Facebook
  • Email
Posted in Cycling, Garmin Edge 800 - Tagged discoverer, edge 800, garmin, mapping, maps, ordnance survey, talkytoaster, velomap
  • camfran

    I find the OS maps really difficult to follow and use when cycling – there’s so much detail that it’s very hard to tell what’s coming up or around on the map at a quick glance. I love the idea of having these beautiful maps on my 800, and they’re great for planning, but mid-ride ended up going back to City Navigator Europe for actual in-ride route navigation – partly to be able to do automotive mode with its perspectival view ahead.

    • Alan

      Do you follow gpx tracks or tcx courses? I find that tcx courses are the better option on the edge 800, as you get little pop up cues which resemble the clarity of the city navigator view. You can also switch the view from top = North, to top = direction of travel (but this can get confusing!)

  • http://openmtbmap.org openmtbmap.org

    Well you better select the GPS layout on the Velomap if you lack contrast.

    You activated the desktop layout – which is especially made to be low contrast – as high contrast on your big screen is awful. If you’ld change to the classic layout on the Velomap – then you would discover it is clearly much more contrast than the other 2 maps.

Follow

Follow me on FacebookFollow me on TwitterFollow me on FlickrFollow me on YouTubeFollow me on RSS

Search

We'll email you about new posts!

Current Deals

£15 off when you spend £100
Use code 15-OFF



Great deals on GARMIN GPS
Garmin 500
Use coupon code PARCEL10
to get it for £161.99!

Most popular

  • How I got Strava premium FREE for a year.How I got Strava premium FREE for a year.
  • Garmin Edge 800: why you shouldn’t bother with custom OSM maps.Garmin Edge 800: why you shouldn’t bother with custom OSM maps.
  • Lock your GPS data against bicycle thievesLock your GPS data against bicycle thieves
  • Tutorial: How to export anyone’s Strava ride as a GPX file.Tutorial: How to export anyone’s Strava ride as a GPX file.
  • Garmin maps comparison – City Navigator and OS DiscovererGarmin maps comparison – City Navigator and OS Discoverer

Recent posts

  • Lock your GPS data against bicycle thieves
  • How I got Strava premium FREE for a year.
  • Darlin’, you got Stink-Kit. Dealing with PermaFunk.
  • GoPro video from Rhyl CC club run – May 6th 2012.
  • Rhyl CC May 6th 2012. Stills from the GoPro Hero2
  • Cycling without numbers – do you really need a cycle computer?
  • April 2012 ride stats
  • 5 reasons why MapMyRide sucks
  • Tutorial: How to export anyone’s Strava ride as a GPX file.
  • Etape Cymru 2012. Let’s get it right this time.
  • New site template
  • What is twitter saying about #strava?
  • Strava as a scapegoat for reckless cyclist behaviour
  • When will North Wales emerge from the digital dark ages?
  • Strava… the gamification of cycling.

android apps bike stats charity cheshire cat communication Customer service cycling deals discoverer edge 800 etape cymru fundraising garmin gopro gps iphone mapmyride mapping maps navigation open streetmap ordnance survey OS OSM redhill Rhyl CC sands smartphone snowdon social media sportive Strava Sunday Club Run talkytoaster time trial training TT Twitter velomap video Videosong walk wiggle youtube

WP-Cumulus by Roy Tanck requires Flash Player 9 or better.


ProBikeKit

EvoLve theme by Theme4Press  •  Powered by WordPress Scarlet Fire
A personal blog.

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.